Wednesday, 14 November 2018

Battle Ravens, wargames, and history

In my recent post about playing the upcoming game Battle Ravens, I talked about the challenges of writing historical wargames and board games. It's something I've been thinking about a lot lately in conjunction with my work on the Gaming a Crusader Castle project.

Battle Ravens is an interesting game in this respect. In one way, it's essentially an abstract strategy game. You could absolutely rename the two sides Red and Blue and change the Ravens to Energy Points and you would still have a fun game. Indeed, the currency being called "ravens" doesn't make an enormous amount of sense other than thematically. Ravens, like wolves and eagles, are associated with battlefields in Old Norse poetry, but you'd think that more ravens would appear as the dead started to pile up.

These ones are getting ready for it to pop off.
People often talk about historical gaming as a "simulation," but I don't know that that's really a useful idea for a game like this one. Simulation presupposes a level of knowledge about the realities of early medieval combat that I just don't know we can claim. Historical accounts of battles are either highly poetic or very matter of fact -- "and the Danes had the victory," that kind of thing. We don't necessarily know what shieldwall combat was really like. Was it the kind of tentative skirmishing envisioned by John Keegan, with sudden bursts of fighting flaring up here and there, or was it more of your phalanx-style shoving match? 

Battle Ravens takes the view that it's all about the nebulous quantity represented by the ravens -- "momentum," perhaps, or "initiative," or maybe "cohesion" -- and about forcing a breach in the enemy's line where both numbers and elan are lacking. I think that is as reasonable an understanding of shieldwall combat as any. 

Of course, in reality there's no thousand-foot general allocating "initiative" to the different parts of the army, but other than directing reserves I don't know what a general in this kind of showdown is supposed to do in real life. It feels like most of the real tactical work is done before the fighting starts -- or at least you hope it is. 

So in general what I'm looking for in a game -- in historical terms, that is -- is not so much "does it accurately model this aspect of early medieval life?" I'm not sure I believe that's really possible. I'm more interested in "does it feel early medieval," but I recognise that that's a very subjective question. Perhaps I mean that I want to know if the game makes you think about some aspect of the early middle ages. And I think that Battle Ravens, for all its simplicity, does a bit. 

Here's the info about Battle Ravens again: Battle Ravens is going on Kickstarter on 20 November 2018; the Kickstarter will go until 6 December. Expected release date is April 2019. Retail price will probably be £35, but Kickstarter backers will be able to get the game for £30 plus a free Scottish army pack. The core game will include Anglo-Saxon and Norse armies, but they plan on making Norman, Scottish and Welsh ones for separate purchase; each will include counters and tactics cards. I reviewed a promotional pre-production copy of the game. 

13 comments:

  1. Nice article thanks for sharing.I know how to focus on homework help.

    ReplyDelete
  2. If your query is I want to pay someone to do my coursework online or buy coursework online Then MyAssignmenthelp.com is the best place for this.

    ReplyDelete
  3. So far, I found this website very professional for assignment writing. I took Assignment Help from them for my Science homework. I am really happy with the experience and I will recommend this website to you guys if you need quality writing services for your project.
    I had to complete my English assignment and I was worried because my assignment was not ready. I took the help from google but still fail to write. Then, I took Assignment Help Online from greatassignmenthelp and I was amazed by the work I received. Their expert provided me the instant support and helped me in my assignment. Thank you guys for your assignment help and support.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Are you facing technical issues while installing cartridges on your HP printer? Does this issue hampering your business productivity and also causing loss of productive hours? What happen if your printer cartridge is not installed correctly and you can’t print your urgent document when it needed the most? For every problem, you need to pursue the proper steps to eliminate the issue. If you want to know the steps to install cartridge properly, then you can dial HP customer support phone number to make connection with third party experts. They will dictate the whole procedure to conquer your problem in an efficient manner

    ReplyDelete
  5. Livewebtutors aims at providing the students with a one stop solution for all the academic related issues. The company has Livewebtutors is an online Assignment Help and assignment writing service offering expert assignment help. Hire Australian assignment writing experts.
    visit now:- my assignment help

    ReplyDelete
  6. If you missed your assignment submission date and you need your assignment to be done in 24 hours then don’t worry just take support from assignment help online service to complete your task on time.Assignment Help Online

    ReplyDelete
  7. Computer science students who need to submit their assignment based on Haskell programming can look for Programming Assignment Help.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Great Post!Quicken is a personal financial accounting software filled with functionalities that are extremely convenient for the user. It does however sometimes get overwhelmed with a variety of different error series. These different series of errors could make your life difficult if you don’t have an idea to resolve them. You might need to contact technical support team via dialing Quicken Customer Service Number from time to time, as Quicken can still be affected with numerous errors that could cause you a lot of problems and hamper your busy schedule. The Quicken Customer Service Phone Number will connect you to advisors who will offer you extremely effective solutions to any errors that you are facing.
    Quicken Customer Support Number
    Quicken Customer Support Phone Number
    Quicken Customer Support

    Quicken Online Backup
    Quicken support Phone number
    Quicken Support Number
    Quicken Error OL-301-A
    quicken error cc-506
    Quicken Error CC-800

    ReplyDelete
  9. Thank you for sharing this informative post.MyAssignmenthelp.co.uk is giving assignment help to students and provides flawless assistance to the students who struggle to write complicated dissertation help. His perfect assistance in the nursing assignment help is praised by all.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Remaining night time we played our first sport of warfare ravens, these days released shield wall ... The scots have been a little cannier and stored their warfare ravens until the Norse used... Irregular wars: wargaming at the world's give up. I want to more time spend but tomorrow it's my assignment & i am searching to Someone to Write my Assignment :). Anyways really enjoying to playing.

    ReplyDelete
  11. P.c games' war Ravens is coming to Kick starter very quickly and in case you're ... battle Ravens is a sport of Viking Age war: a brutal conflict of strength, Fight for your Faction In world Of Shield wolf War game & Terrain | Info Delivered by Intelligent Essays.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Thanks for your post, Need law assignment Help Online? Our experts provide completely plagiarism-free and unique assignment writing solutions at your desk. Our writing services are not only affordable but also deliver premium quality content. We cover most of the areas that are related to Law subject with optimum brilliance. Law Assignment Help writers proffer all the necessary help and guidance at an affordable rate.
    Law Assignment Help
    Law Assignment Homework Help

    ReplyDelete