Wednesday, 14 November 2018

Battle Ravens, wargames, and history

In my recent post about playing the upcoming game Battle Ravens, I talked about the challenges of writing historical wargames and board games. It's something I've been thinking about a lot lately in conjunction with my work on the Gaming a Crusader Castle project.

Battle Ravens is an interesting game in this respect. In one way, it's essentially an abstract strategy game. You could absolutely rename the two sides Red and Blue and change the Ravens to Energy Points and you would still have a fun game. Indeed, the currency being called "ravens" doesn't make an enormous amount of sense other than thematically. Ravens, like wolves and eagles, are associated with battlefields in Old Norse poetry, but you'd think that more ravens would appear as the dead started to pile up.

These ones are getting ready for it to pop off.
People often talk about historical gaming as a "simulation," but I don't know that that's really a useful idea for a game like this one. Simulation presupposes a level of knowledge about the realities of early medieval combat that I just don't know we can claim. Historical accounts of battles are either highly poetic or very matter of fact -- "and the Danes had the victory," that kind of thing. We don't necessarily know what shieldwall combat was really like. Was it the kind of tentative skirmishing envisioned by John Keegan, with sudden bursts of fighting flaring up here and there, or was it more of your phalanx-style shoving match? 

Battle Ravens takes the view that it's all about the nebulous quantity represented by the ravens -- "momentum," perhaps, or "initiative," or maybe "cohesion" -- and about forcing a breach in the enemy's line where both numbers and elan are lacking. I think that is as reasonable an understanding of shieldwall combat as any. 

Of course, in reality there's no thousand-foot general allocating "initiative" to the different parts of the army, but other than directing reserves I don't know what a general in this kind of showdown is supposed to do in real life. It feels like most of the real tactical work is done before the fighting starts -- or at least you hope it is. 

So in general what I'm looking for in a game -- in historical terms, that is -- is not so much "does it accurately model this aspect of early medieval life?" I'm not sure I believe that's really possible. I'm more interested in "does it feel early medieval," but I recognise that that's a very subjective question. Perhaps I mean that I want to know if the game makes you think about some aspect of the early middle ages. And I think that Battle Ravens, for all its simplicity, does a bit. 

Here's the info about Battle Ravens again: Battle Ravens is going on Kickstarter on 20 November 2018; the Kickstarter will go until 6 December. Expected release date is April 2019. Retail price will probably be £35, but Kickstarter backers will be able to get the game for £30 plus a free Scottish army pack. The core game will include Anglo-Saxon and Norse armies, but they plan on making Norman, Scottish and Welsh ones for separate purchase; each will include counters and tactics cards. I reviewed a promotional pre-production copy of the game. 

7 comments:

  1. Ducat is one of the sap training institute in noida with 100% placement support. Ducat has well defined course modules and training sessions for students. At Ducat ERP SAP training is conducted during day time classes, weekend classes, evening batch classes and fast track training classes.

    sap training in noida

    Downloading Adda

    ReplyDelete
  2. How to rectify the Gmail not receiving emails problem?
    Gmail is one of the largest web and app-based email service providers across the globe, and it provides best in class services to its users, but sometimes the users may face some common issues like the Gmail not receiving some emails , and this can be caused because of bad network connection or incompatible browser that you use to access Gmail services.

    ReplyDelete
  3. How to troubleshoot Yahoo Mail not receiving Emails?
    Yahoo is though one of the best online mail services, users in few instances get stuck after getting the most common technical issue of Yahoo Mail not receiving Emails. However, this sort of issue, you can get resolved easily and instantly with our tech expert team.

    ReplyDelete
  4. How to change the Verizon Wi-Fi password?
    You have to log in to the router device using its administrator account and its administrator password to change Verizon Wi-Fi password . The device can combine both modem and router functions, and they will be separated devices. You can use your browser. The router has the address 192.168.1.1 on your local area network. Then within the security section, you can find where you'll be able to assign a replacement passphrase for Wi-Fi connections.

    ReplyDelete
  5. What a wonderful piece of article I have bookmarked for future checkup. A capstone paper is normally a lengthy academic document that demonstrates a student’s ability to conduct independent research and to communicate the findings or the results in an academic manner. This type of academic paper follows a conventional format and it is normally written by students during their final year of pursuing a given programme. Learn more on Capstone Writing Services .

    ReplyDelete